The Pros and Cons of Selling Your Classic Car Privately vs. Through a Dealer

The Pros and Cons of Selling Your Classic Car Privately vs. Through a Dealer

Are you at a crossroads, wondering whether to sell your beloved classic car privately or through a dealership? Both options have their advantages and drawbacks, and making the right choice can significantly impact your selling experience and the final sale price. In this blog, we’ll delve into the pros and cons of selling your classic car privately and through a dealer to help you make an informed decision.

Selling Your Classic Car Privately


Higher Sale Price Potential: When selling privately, you have the potential to command a higher sale price for your classic car. Without a middleman, you can negotiate directly with buyers, often resulting in a better deal.

Personal Connection: Private sales allow you to engage with potential buyers who share your passion for classic cars. You can find a buyer who truly appreciates the unique features of your vehicle.

Full Control: You maintain complete control over the sale process, including pricing, negotiations, and the terms of the sale. You can also set the terms for the exchange of the vehicle.

No Dealer Fees: You won’t have to pay dealer commissions or fees, which can be substantial when selling through a dealership.

Flexibility: You can take your time with the sale, waiting for the right buyer and the best offer.


Time-Consuming: Selling privately often takes longer than going through a dealer. You’ll need to invest time in advertising, responding to inquiries, and conducting negotiations.

Handling the Details: You’re responsible for all aspects of the sale, including paperwork, safety inspections, and ensuring the transaction is secure.

Privacy Concerns: Inviting strangers to your property for test drives can be a security risk, and you may be concerned about sharing your personal information.

Limited Marketing Reach: You may not have the extensive marketing resources or reach that a dealership offers, potentially limiting your pool of potential buyers.

Negotiation Challenges: Some buyers may try to negotiate aggressively, and you’ll need to be prepared for this aspect of private sales.

Selling Your Classic Car Through a Dealer


Convenience: Dealerships handle all the aspects of the sale, from advertising to negotiations and paperwork, making the process more convenient for sellers.

Broader Market Reach: Dealerships often have a network of potential buyers and collectors, providing access to a broader market.

Expertise: Dealerships have experienced staff who can assess the value of your classic car accurately and market it effectively.

Safety and Security: Dealerships can manage the security of the sale process and help ensure your personal information is not compromised.

Trade-Ins: Some dealerships may offer you the option to trade in your classic car for another vehicle or to sell it on consignment.


Lower Sale Price: Dealers typically take a commission or markup, which may lead to a lower sale price for your classic car compared to selling it privately.

Less Control: When selling through a dealer, you relinquish some control over the sale process and may have to comply with their terms.

Limited Personal Connection: Dealership buyers may not share the same passion for your classic car as a private buyer might.

Potential Delays: Depending on market demand and dealer priorities, your classic car sale might take longer than expected.

Dealer Fees: You’ll need to pay dealer fees and potentially incur costs related to preparing your car for sale.

In the end, the decision to sell your classic car privately or through a dealer will depend on your personal preferences, time constraints, and the financial outcome you desire. If you’re looking for the highest possible sale price and are willing to invest time and effort, selling privately might be the way to go. However, if convenience and a broader market reach are more appealing, a dealership might be your best option. Weigh the pros and cons carefully to make an informed choice that aligns with your goals and priorities.


Affordable Classics San Diego specializes in purchasing classic cars. In 3 steps we’ll take the stress off selling privately and the risk of losing money at auctions by allowing you to sell your classic car online.


Related Articles